The UEEX shares the vision of the integration of the electricity market between the EU and Ukraine
On November 22, the Ukrainian business community "Energy Club" organized an online discussion devoted to the prospects of Ukraine’s integration into European electricity markets and further steps in this process. The panel was part of a wider energy security conference covering a range of topics related to Ukraine’s energy security.
Leading experts and representatives of Ukrainian and EU electricity stakeholders presented their vision for the further integration of the Ukrainian electricity market with the EU after Ukraine’s accession to the energy networks of continental Europe. The Ukrainian Energy Exchange was represented by business developer Lisse Gert van Vliet.
Mr. van Vliet began his presentation by assessing the tremendous work of those who are working today to restore and maintain the networks that provide Ukrainian homes with light, heat and gas. He emphasized that one of the most important things is that Ukraine has preserved a competitive model of the electricity market, despite the difficulties that the energy sector is currently facing. Referring to ACER’s report on European wholesale electricity markets, he reiterated that competitive markets work in favor of the consumer even in times of crisis. Ongoing initiatives to further implement the current market design through a number of existing EU rules and regulations will bring additional benefits. Conversely, ill-conceived emergency measures or distortion of price signals by interfering with market price formation could lead to a curtailment of EU market integration and overall competition, thereby jeopardizing the benefits achieved so far and possibly increasing the overall cost of the future energy transition.
Mr. van Vliet outlined the steps that Ukraine will need to take to facilitate further integration of Ukraine’s short-term and long-term electricity markets with EU markets. According to him, there are some barriers that must be removed before the unification of the Ukrainian market will take place with the help of a single intraday or a single day-ahead unification. In particular, issues of taxation, currency and access to capacity still remain. In addition, it will be necessary to change a significant part of the regulatory support of the market and allow non-residents to work in the electricity market of Ukraine. Bandwidth must be allocated using implicit allocation methods and it must be guaranteed. The task of Market Coupling is the equalization of prices in the zones taking into account the permissible value of the intersection, therefore one must be aware of the inadmissibility of using individual price restrictions in the unified market. In addition, it was stated that the monopoly model for the Designated Electricity Market Operator (NEMO) in Ukraine is undesirable, as competition stimulates innovation and investment in the market. Competition between electricity exchanges has shown clear advantages in the EU markets, so it would be better to choose a competitive model. But even a monopoly NEMO must meet the eligibility criteria, appointing a single NEMO Ukraine must be confident in its ability to provide market connection, otherwise it carries great risks for the country.
In the second part of his presentation, Mr. van Vliet expressed his views on the next steps to facilitate the integration of forward markets, as one of ACER’s recommendations for improving markets. Competitive long-term electricity markets play a key role in risk management, thus supporting investment. Until Ukraine joined the pan-European distribution systems of cross-border crossings with the possibility of buying crossings in both directions. This is an important issue for improving bilateral trade. One of the issues is standardization, so UEEX has already taken the first steps in this direction by launching the possibility to trade standardized contracts based on a bilateral counter-auction. The implementation of REMIT is among other key issues. While the law is being prepared for the second reading, the UEEX already reports all transactions to the NSSMC and fulfills all requirements regulating organized trade, including in terms of preventing and countering manipulation. Market integration ensures cheaper electricity across Europe and promotes the development of renewable energy sources.
In addition to ongoing initiatives to further take advantage of electricity market integration, the energy system will face new challenges ahead as it seeks to achieve the EU’s ambitious decarbonisation trajectory. Therefore, Ukraine should also continue to move in this direction. In Ukraine, legislation has been created for the launch of PPA, but there are still a number of obstacles to export green electricity, since the register of guarantees of origin has not been implemented, which, in turn, will also have to overcome obstacles to free cross-border trade with the EU with guarantees of origin from the countries of the Energy Community. The implementation of the CBAM will be a very powerful challenge for Ukraine, if no consensus is reached on this issue. For now, a number of criteria must be met for exclusion, in particular, the need to achieve climate neutrality by 2050, the implementation of an ETS for electricity with price parity with the EU ETS, and the obligation not to import electricity from countries that do not meet these criteria, etc. The main question here will be under what circumstances a non-EU ETS can be considered equivalent.
Mr. van Vleet also briefly touched on the recent ACER-CEER proposal to directly connect the forward market and opportunities for Ukraine.
As a result, even in the most difficult conditions, the Ukrainian market demonstrates stable operation. He demonstrated the results of electricity trading in the market segment of bilateral contracts at the UEEX platforms.

