Electricity: Ukraine and Europe September 25 – 29, 2023

Ukrainian Energy Exchange: bilateral contracts market
During the last week, 18 auctions for the purchase/sale of electricity were held at the UEEX in the one-way auction mode, of which 7 were in commercial sections and 11 were in specialized sections. Among the initiators were represented: Energoatom - Trading, Guaranteed buyer, Centerenergo, Donbasenergo, Ukrhydroenergo, Kharkiv TPP-5, Aquaresurs-1, Shamrayiv tsukor, Starokostiantinivtsukor, USP and DSO, etc.
Energoatom-Trading initiated auctions in accordance with Article 66 of the Law of Ukraine "On the electricity market", where it offered a base load with delivery in October. The company was able to sold 86,600 MWh with a weighted average price of UAH 3,682.12/MWh.
Last week, the Energoatom-Trading company initiated an auction in the form of a special session for the sale of packages of lots under bilateral contracts for JSC "Ukrzaliznytsia", where it offered a base load with delivery for the fourth quarter of 2023. The company sold 662,700 MWh at a price of UAH 3,200/MWh.
The Kharkiv CHPP-5 company initiated an auction where it offered a base load with a supply period of October 2023, selling 73,010 MWh. at the weighted average price of 3694.29 MWh.
In addition, Donbasenergo sold 180,250 MWh of base load electricity in specialized sections last week at a weighted average price of UAH 3,690.6/MWh with delivery in October, Aquaresurs – 2,976 MWh of block position (8-23) at a weighted average price of UAH 4,700/MWh, 8,940 MWh of base load at a weighted average price of UAH 3,850/MWh with a delivery period of October 2023.
Starokostiantinivtsukor, where he offered a base load with delivery for the first decade of October. Starokostyantinivtsukor was able to sold 240 MWh of base load at a weighted average price of UAH 3,676/MWh. Shamrayiv tsukor sold 336 MWh at a weighted average price of UAH 3,654/MWh.
During the review period, auctions were initiated by the Guaranteed Buyer, offering block positions of daytime hours with October delivery. According to the results of the auctions, the company sold 89,600 MWh of electricity at prices in the range of UAH 2,058.95 - UAH 3,232.55/MWh.
In the commercial sections, the companies purchased electricity by the load of an individual profile.
| Type of trades | Sales volume, MWh |
|---|---|
| Auctions in fulfillment of Article 66 of the Law on the Electricity Market | 352 352 |
| Commercial section | 72 878,581 |
| Special sessions on the sale of electricity produced from alternative energy sources | 89 600 |
| Special session on the sale of packages of lots under bilateral contracts (clauses 47-54 of the Procedure) | 662 700 |
| In total | 1 177 530,581 |
As of September 29, prices were formed for the most frequently used types of sales charts presented on the chart.
Market operator: day-ahead market and intraday market
During the review period, prices were dynamic, being in the range of UAH 3423.85 - 4385.97/MWh, within ±16% of the deviation relative to the average weekly value. In general, the average value of the weighted average price for the last week increased relative to the similar indicator of the previous week and amounted to UAH 3,962.08/MWh (+6 %). A total of 325.17 thousand MWh was implemented at the DAM during the review period. (+9.6%).
During the review period, prices were even more dynamic on the IDM. Average weighted prices varied in the range of 2,570.55 - 5,073.01 MWh, and the average value of weighted average prices for the review period increased by 4% relative to the similar indicator of the previous period and amounted to UAH 4,133.56/MWh. The total volume of purchase and sale during the review period amounted to 10.5 thousand MWh.
European market
Last week, prices on European electricity markets were higher, while gas prices, after Monday’s peak values, fell on September 26 by 9.3%. Electricity market experts note that the market is entering the winter period in "better shape" than last year, although a very cold winter could still trigger the threat of gas shortages, which would also affect electricity markets in turn. The increase in seasonal demand is expected to be offset by improvements in French nuclear and European wind generation, which together added a total of 14 GW compared to last year.
Solar energy generation decreased in all analyzed markets, but also during this period, the Spanish market on Sunday, September 24, reached the highest level of solar thermoelectric energy production since the beginning of September - 22 GWh.
According to the results of the study, solar PPAs topped the technology ranking in Europe, as the majority of new contracts were concluded with photovoltaic plants. This means that in recent years, most of the new PPAs are related to solar PV, pushing wind energy into second place. New players include Spain, Germany, Denmark, Poland, as well as France, Italy and Greece. The weighted average price index of solar PPAs in Europe in the II quarter of 2023 amounted to 72.02 EUR/MWh.
Wind power generation in Europe in the first four days of last week provided 14.6% of the region’s needs, according to the WindEurope association. At the same time, the leading countries were Germany, Spain, Great Britain and Sweden.
Demand in most analyzed markets continued to decline last week. Electricity demand could show its first significant year-over-year increase in October, with fourth-quarter average demand forecast to be 2% higher year-on-year.
Regarding hourly prices, on the Spanish market on Sunday, September 24, from 12:00 to 16:00, the price was 0 EUR/MWh. On the Italian market on the same day from 13:00 to 15:00 a price of EUR 10.00/MWh was registered, the lowest since May. On the market of the Nordic countries, negative hourly prices were reached on September 25 and 26. In the case of the British market, a negative hourly price was registered on September 25.
As of September 29, the basic electricity price in France was 94.72 EUR/MWh, in Hungary: 105.85 EUR/MWh, in Poland 113.67 EUR/MWh. As of October 2023, electricity was traded in the range of EUR 92-105/MWh.
Monthly futures for November 2023 on electricity increased by an average of 15.8% in the analyzed countries. As of December 2023, prices in Hungary and France increased by 11% on average and decreased by 1% in Poland.
Prices of futures contracts, EUR/MWh, 09/28/2023
| Тype | Contract | Date | France | Hungary | Poland |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base | Моnth | Oct/23 | 91,84 | 105,25 | 104,01 |
| Nov/23 | 115,51 | 124,01 | 108,08 | ||
| Dec/23 | 125,08 | 127,67 | 107,39 |
Last week, European carbon prices eased on Tuesday to the lowest in more than three months as lower gas prices boosted the fuel’s profitability in power generation and reduced forecast demand for EUA.
CO 2 futures prices on the EEX market for benchmark December 2023 contracts hit a settlement of EUR 82.71/t on Thursday, September 28, down 1.7% from the 2 weeks ago.
European importers are facing rising prices and administrative difficulties as the impact is felt in anticipation of the EU’s new Carbon Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) coming into effect next month, with the first reporting obligations covering the fourth quarter of 2023, must be provided by January 31, 2024. Analysts expect auction volumes to reach their highest level for the year in October and then in November as a result of the REPowerEU deal. In the fourth quarter, prices are likely to average EUR 81.23 per tonne of CO2 equivalent.
The spot price of thermal coal in Europe (according to API-2) on Thursday, September 28, was EUR 116.52/ton, which is 1.5% higher than the previous indicator. With a narrowing gap as gas and coal compete on price, the fourth quarter is predicted to see a dynamic fuel shift amid tight margins and relatively volatile gas prices.
Last week, the CHPP plant in the southern region of Ukraine was damaged due to enemy shelling. Exports were made to Slovakia and Moldova, imports came from Slovakia.
Public procurement
Over 50 tenders for the purchase of electricity by customers were held last week. The sold volume of the 10 largest contracts is 8.52 million kWh for the total cost of UAH 38.73 million excluding VAT. In general, the average price was UAH 4.91 per kWh excluding VAT. The largest contract was received by "Energoprod Service" LLC, which will supply 3 million kWh of electricity to the Apartment and Operation Department of Bila Tserkva at the initial price of UAH 4.41 per kWh excluding VAT. Other tenders are shown in the graph below. Prices ranged from UAH 4.27 to 5.99/kWh.
News of the wholesale electricity market
The NEURC approved the procedure for investigating abuses on the wholesale energy market. This was the decision of the NEURC at its meeting on September 26. Abuses in the wholesale energy market include: violation of established restrictions on the use of insider information; manipulation and attempts to manipulate the electricity and/or natural gas market; non-disclosure or disclosure of insider information in violation of the requirements established for the disclosure of such information; carrying out transactions with wholesale energy products without registering as a wholesale energy market participant. NEURC will first conduct a preliminary study that will determine the feasibility of further investigation. A preliminary investigation may begin based on the results of monitoring of economic and trade operations related to wholesale energy products; on the basis of a notification from the applicants or a notification from the Council of Regulatory Authorities of the Energy Community or national energy authorities of European countries. After the start of the investigation, the regulator will have the right to demand from market participants copies of documents, information, data and explanations on issues related to the object of the investigation. For their part, the market participants will be obliged to provide the NEURC with the requested documents or information in electronic form with the imposition of a qualified electronic signature of an authorized person or a qualified electronic seal of a business entity.
In Ukraine, after the modernization, another power unit of the DTEK Energo TPP put into operation one of the power units of the TPP after deconservation and modernization, this allows to increase the capacity of the country’s power system by an additional up to 225 MW. This was reported in DTEK, reports Ukrinform. "Today, the power engineers of one of the DTEK Energo thermal power plants put one of the power units into operation after deconservation and modernization. Its return to full operation makes it possible to increase the capacity of the energy system (the country - ed.) by an additional up to 225 MWh," the message says. It is noted that only in September, thanks to the repairs and modernization of the energy industry, the company introduced four power units into the power system, as a result of which it was possible to increase its capacity to almost 800 MWh. As reported, in general, in September 2023, the company "DTEK Energo" completed repairs on three power units of the TPP with a total maximum capacity of up to 570 MWh.


