Electricity: Ukraine and Europe September 11 – 15, 2023

Ukrainian Energy Exchange: bilateral contracts market
Last week, 8 auctions for the purchase/sale of electricity in the unilateral auction mode were held at UEEX, of which 3 were in commercial sections and 5 in specialized sections. Among the initiators were: Energoatom-Trading, Guaranteed Buyer, Starokonstantinovtsukor, USP and DSOs, etc.
Energoatom-Trading initiated auctions in accordance with Article 66 of the Law of Ukraine "On the Electricity Market", where it offered base-load for delivery in September. The company was able to sell 158112 MWh at a weighted average price of 3476,39 UAH/MWh with a delivery period of September 13-30 and 65664 MWh at a weighted average price of 3463,36 UAH/MWh with a delivery period of September 15-30.
During the reporting period, the Guaranteed Buyer initiated auctions offering block positions for daytime hours with delivery in September. According to the results of the auction, the company sold 36800 MWh of electricity at prices in the range of 1700 - 3365.06 UAH/MWh with delivery in September.
In addition, Starokonstantinovtsukor sold electricity in the specialized section last week, offering base-load with delivery in September. Starokostiantynivtsukor managed to sell 192 MWh of baseload at a weighted average price of 3300 UAH/MWh.
In commercial sections, the companies mainly purchased electricity for individual loads.
| Trades type | Sales volume, MWh |
|---|---|
| Auctions pursuant to Article 66 of the Law of Ukraine On Electricity Market | 223 968 |
| Commercial section | 20 511 |
| Special sessions for the sale of electricity generated from alternative energy sources | 36 800 |
| Totaly | 281 279 |
As of September 15, prices for the most commonly used types of sales schedules were formed, as shown in the chart.
Market operator: day-ahead and intraday markets
During the reporting period, prices were dynamic, ranging from UAH 3017,68 to UAH 4330,59/MWh, within ±17% deviation from the weekly average. In general, the average weighted average price for the last week decreased compared to the same indicator of the previous week and amounted to 3791,08 UAH/MWh (-5,11%). In total, 306,96 thousand MWh were sold on the DAM during the reporting period (+9,5%).
During the reporting period, prices on the DAM were even more dynamic. The weighted average prices varied in the range of 3160,98 - 5368,28 MWh, and the average value of the weighted average prices for the reporting period increased by 9,9% compared to the same period last year and amounted to 4213,81 UAH/MWh. The total volume of sales and purchases for the reporting period amounted to 14,39 thousand MWh.
European market
Last week was marked by a decline in wind energy production and an increase in the average gas price, which also led to higher prices on European electricity markets. The markets of Germany, Belgium and the Netherlands recorded the highest hourly prices of more than €300/MWh.
Solar power generation decreased in all analyzed markets. According to the WindEurope association, electricity generation from wind turbines in Europe in the first four days of last week covered 8.4% of the region’s needs, which is 4% less than the week before last indicator. The leading countries were Germany, Spain, the UK and Sweden.
Demand in the analyzed markets increased last week, especially in Italy, the Netherlands, and Portugal.
In terms of hourly prices, on Sunday, September 10, from 14:00 to 15:00, the German, Belgian, French and Dutch markets recorded a price of 0 EUR/MWh. The next day, September 11, prices exceeded 300 EUR/MWh in the German, Belgian and Dutch markets, reaching their highest levels since December 2022. In the Belgian market, the highest price of EUR 330,36/MWh was recorded from 20:00 to 21:00. In the Dutch and German markets, the highest prices were 463,77 EUR/MWh and 524,27 EUR/MWh, respectively, from 19:00 to 20:00.
As of September 15, the price of basic electricity in France decreased and amounted to 95,78 EUR/MWh, in Hungary 109,71 EUR/MWh, in Poland 120,81 EUR/MWh. As of October 2023, electricity was trading in the range of 91-105 EUR/MWh.
Monthly futures for November 2023 for electricity increased by an average of 21,9% in the analyzed countries. As of December 2023, prices in Hungary and France increased by 11% on average and decreased by 6% in Poland.
Futures contract prices, EUR/MWh, September 14, 2023
| Type | Contract | Date | France | Hungary | Poland |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base | Моnth | Oct/23 | 91,26 | 103,97 | 104,92 |
| Nov/23 | 124,68 | 128,43 | 110,59 | ||
| Dec/23 | 142,89 | 138,58 | 104,01 |
Last week, European carbon prices rose from the start of the week while UK allowances fell to a new record low. Prices for CO 2 futures on the EEX market for the benchmark December 2023 contracts on Thursday, September 14, reached a settlement price of EUR 83,12 per ton.
Experts at a special event last Wednesday said that implementing the ambitious 2040 emissions reduction target would increase the fairness of the EU’s global contribution to climate change, but the bloc needs higher carbon prices today to prevent costly and steep price increases in the coming years.
Spot price of thermal coal in Europe (according to API-2) on Thursday, September 14, amounted to 113,36 EUR/ton.
The situation in Ukraine’s power system is stable. Exports during daytime hours were carried out to Slovakia and Moldova.
Public procurements
Over the past week, more than 40 electricity procurement tenders were held by customers. Sold volume of the 10 largest contracts amounted to 58,89 million kWh for a total value of UAH 265,24 million excluding VAT. The average price amounted to UAH 4,8 per kWh, excluding VAT. The largest contract was awarded to Energocenter Plus LLC, which will supply Misksvitlo of the Dnipro City Council to supply 31,1 million kWh of electricity at a starting price of UAH 4,35 per kWh, excluding VAT. Other tenders are shown in the graph below. Prices ranged from UAH 4,33 to 5,87 per kWh.
News from the wholesale electricity market
The regulator has agreed on the rules for allocating cross-border traffic with Slovakia, Poland and Hungary. The regulator has agreed on the rules for allocating cross-border traffic at daily auctions in the directions of Ukraine-Poland, Ukraine-Slovakia and Ukraine-Hungary. The auctions in these directions will be held on the basis of the electronic auction platform Joint Allocation Office (JAO). The decision was made at a meeting on September 12. The Regulator also agreed on the distribution structure for the Ukraine-Slovakia auctions: 0% for annual auctions, 0% for monthly auctions, and 100% for daily auctions.
France plans to introduce long-term contracts for electricity supply. France’s Ministry of Energy Transition has supported EDF’s proposal to introduce multi-year contracts to guarantee price stability for businesses. The company is proposing long-term contracts of 5-10 years in accordance with the new market rules, which EDF could sign with its main customers, whether they are electricity suppliers (such as Engie or TotalEnergies) or end users. The new scheme will replace the current ARENH framework, which is scheduled to be terminated at the end of 2025. The ARENH law (2010) obliges EDF to sell part of its nuclear generation to alternative suppliers on the wholesale market at a regulated price set by the CRE at 42 EUR/MWh since 2012.


