Electricity: Ukraine and Europe October 30 – November 3, 2023

Ukrainian Energy Exchange: bilateral contracts market
During the last week, 8 auctions for the purchase/sale of electricity were held at the UEEX in the one-way auction mode, of which 3 were in commercial sections, and 5 were in specialized sections. Among the initiators were presented: Guaranteed buyer, Centerenergo, Ukrhydroenergo, Donbasenergo, USP and DSO, etc.
The Ukrhydroenergo company initiated auctions where it offered block positions with a release period beginning in November. According to the results, the company was able to sold 2268 MWh of block positions (16-24) at a weighted average price of UAH 5,038.64/MWh with a delivery period of November 4 - 12.
Donbasenergo initiated an auction where the base load was offered with a delivery period in November, the company sold 180,000 MWh at the weighted average price of UAH 3,862.6/MWh.
In addition, in the specialized section last week, Centerenergo initiated auctions in accordance with Article 66 of the Law of Ukraine "On the electricity market", where it offered base load and block positions with delivery in November. As a result, the company was unable to sell electricity.
During the review period, auctions were initiated by the Guaranteed Buyer, offering block positions with delivery in the second decade of November. According to the results of the auctions, the company sold 23,500 MWh of daytime electricity at prices in the range of 2522.84 - 3954.80 UAH/MWh, and block position (1-7) 4550 MWh at a weighted average price of UAH 2,200/MWh.
In the commercial sections of the companies, the purchase/sale of electricity was carried out by the load of an individual profile.
| Type of trades | Sales volume, MWh |
|---|---|
| Auctions in fulfillment of Article 66 of the Law on the Electricity Market | 182 268 |
| Commercial section | 66 654,068 |
| Special sessions on the sale of electricity produced from alternative energy sources | 28 050 |
| In total | 276 972,068 |
As of November 3, prices were formed for the most frequently used types of sales charts, presented in the chart below.
Market operator: day-ahead market and intraday market
During the review period, prices were dynamic, being in the range of UAH 2,860.68 - 4,922.67/MWh, within ±27% of the deviation relative to the average weekly value. In general, the average value of the weighted average price for the last week decreased relative to the similar indicator of the previous week and amounted to UAH 3,702.61/MWh (-13%). A total of 388.3 thousand MWh was sold at the DAM during the review period. (-3.4%).
During the review period, prices were even more dynamic on the IDM. Average weighted prices varied in the range of 2276.04 - 5235.93 MWh, and the average value of weighted average prices for the review period decreased by 10% relative to the similar indicator of the previous period and amounted to UAH 3814.18/MWh. The total volume of sales during the review period amounted to 17.5 thousand MWh.
European market
Last week, some European electricity markets reached minimum prices, although there was an unplanned reduction in gas supplies in the North Sea and failures at two French nuclear plants.
Wind power generation in Europe in the first four days of last week provided 26.5% of the region’s needs, according to the WindEurope association. At the same time, the leading countries were Germany, France, Spain and Great Britain. Also, the MIBEL market registered the lowest prices in Europe thanks to wind energy. This year, Germany issued a record number of new permits for the construction of wind farms, allowing Berlin to offer more than 6 gigawatts of contracts at auctions through 2023. Most major European electricity markets saw a decline in solar output compared to the previous week.
Portugal and the UK have seen demand pick up over the past week. Catholic holidays were celebrated in Poland for two days in a row, November 1 and 2, which accordingly reduced demand.
Last week, most markets, with the exception of Italy and Northern Europe, recorded zero or negative hourly prices over the weekend.
As of November 3, the basic electricity price in France was 57.11 EUR/MWh, in Hungary: 67.20 EUR/MWh, in Poland: 80.20 EUR/MWh. As of December 2023, electricity was traded in the range of 90-110 EUR/MWh.
Monthly futures for January 2024 on electricity increased by an average of 11.4% in Poland and France and decreased by 1.6% in Hungary. As of February 2024, prices in Hungary and France increased by 15.3% on average.
Prices of futures contracts, EUR/MWh, 02.11.2023
| Type | Contract | Date | France | Hungary | Poland |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base | Моnth | Dec/23 | 103,23 | 110,20 | 89,54 |
| Jan/24 | 128,40 | 108,39 | 114,29 | ||
| Feb/24 | 139,08 | 143,75 | - |
European carbon prices ended October 3.2% lower than a month earlier. This is part of a general downward trend in prices since the end of February, when prices reached EUR 100 per tonne. Since then, prices have been falling and moving away from the level of EUR 100/t.
CO 2 futures prices on the EEX market for benchmark December 2023 contracts settled at EUR 78.61/t on Thursday, November 2, down 1.3% from the previous week.
An analytical report published on Thursday forecast that EU ETS emissions from heavy industry should fall by 7% in 2023 compared to a year earlier due to a fall in production, particularly among steel and chemical companies. The steel and aluminum sectors are the main sources of CO2 emissions and excess capacity, and neither industry is on track to achieve zero emissions by 2050. Negotiations between the US and the EU on the Global Agreement on Clean Steel and Aluminum will continue until the end of 2023, after no agreement was reached at the last summit. Without a deal, US steel and aluminum tariffs with the EU could be reinstated in 2024.
The spot price of thermal coal in Europe (according to API-2) on Thursday, November 2, was EUR 116.56/ton.
Last week, Russian aggressors attacked energy facilities. After the shelling of the energy industry, consumers in the front-line regions and Poltava Region were cut off.
Exports were made to Slovakia, Romania and Moldova. On October 30, "green" generation was limited due to the surplus. Imports also came from Slovakia, Romania and Moldova.
Public procurement
Over 60 tenders for the purchase of electricity by customers were held last week. The sold volume of the 10 largest contracts is 9.39 million kWh for the total cost of UAH 46.91 million excluding VAT. In general, the average price was UAH 5.16. per kWh excluding VAT. The largest contract was awarded to "Ukrainian Stream" LLC, which will supply 2.1 million kWh to the "Novoyavorivskvodokanal" MKP. electricity at the initial price of UAH 4.59 per kWh excluding VAT. Other tenders are shown in the graph below. Prices ranged from UAH 4.18 to 6.54/kWh.
News of the wholesale electricity market
NEURC initiates a 4-23% increase in marginal prices for electricity for business. The NEURC proposes to raise the limit prices (price caps) for electricity on the day-ahead market by 4-23%. NEURC proposes to divide the day into several hour zones, during which the following limit prices for the "day-ahead" market (DAM) will apply: • for minimum load hours (from 00:00 to 7:00 and from 23:00 to 24:00) – UAH 3,000 per MWh; • for hours of average load (from 7:00 to 8:00, from 11:00 to 17:00 and from 22:00 to 23:00) – UAH 5,600 per MWh; • for hours of increased load (from 8:00 a.m. to 11:00 a.m.) – UAH 6,900 per MWh; • for hours of maximum load (from 17:00 to 22:00) – UAH 7,500 per MWh. The NEURC plans to approve the final decision on raising the price caps in November 2023, and they will be valid until May 2024.
The Cabinet of Ministers has approved the Regulations on Import Features. The Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine approved the Regulation on the peculiarities of the import of electricity in the conditions of the legal regime of martial law in Ukraine. According to the Regulation, which was published on October 30, the operator of the distribution system is obliged, in the event of the application of measures for the forced limitation of electricity supply to consumers at the command of the operator of the transmission system for operational safety, not to apply such measures to non-domestic consumers whose total electricity consumption in in each billing hour, the volume of purchased imported electrical energy is at least 30% during May-September and 50% during October-April. In the event that the volume of purchased imported electricity in the corresponding billing hour is less than 30 percent during May-September and 50 percent during October-April of the total volume of consumption by such a consumer in each billing hour, the distribution system operator shall resume the application of measures to force the limitation of electricity supply starting from the time of detection of this fact and before the end of the delivery day.


