Electricity: Ukraine and Europe March 27 – 31, 2023

Ukrainian Energy Exchange: bilateral contracts market
During the last week, 26 auctions for the purchase/sale of electricity were held at the UEEX in the one-way auction mode, of which 6 were in commercial sections and 20 were in specialized sections. Among the initiators were presented: Energoatom - Trading, Ukrhydroenergo, Centerenergo, Kharkiv TPP-5, Donbasenergo, Guaranteed buyer, companies of the DTEK group, Euro-reconstruction, Cherkasy chemical fiber, USP and DSO, etc.
During the review period, the Energoatom-Trading company initiated auctions in accordance with Article 66 of the Law of Ukraine "On the electricity market", where it offered base load with supply during April. The company was able to sell 275.18 thousand MWh at the weighted average price of UAH 2,701.18/MWh.
Initiated auctions Guaranteed buyer, offering block positions of daytime hours in April. According to their results, the company sold 8100 MWh block positions at weighted average prices in the range of 2,686.09 - 3,016.25 UAH/MWh.
Last week, Ukrhydroenergo was offered electricity with supply for April. The company was able to realize 11,424 MWh of block positions (24-7) at the weighted average price of UAH 1,575/MWh, 20,860 MWh of maximum load at prices in the range of UAH 3,000 - 3,700.51/MWh.
In the review period, the Centerenergo company initiated auctions where it offered base load and block positions with delivery in April. According to their results, the company was able to sell 42,480 MWh of base load at prices in the range of 2703.06 - 2720 UAH/MWh, 17120 MWh of maximum load (8-23), 33120 MWh of minimum load (24-7) at prices 3280 - 3285; 1550 - 1630 UAH/MWh respectively.
The companies DTEK Kurakhivska TPP, Dniproenergo and Zahidenergo initiated auctions in accordance with Article 66 of the Law of Ukraine "On the electricity market", where block positions with supply for April were offered. The companies were able to sell a total of 2064.21 thousand MWh, at prices in the range of 1500-2880 UAH/MWh.
In addition, Donbasenergo sold electricity in specialized sections last week - with a supply period of April. The company realized 48,000 MWh of minimum load (24-7) at a weighted average price of UAH 1,650.6/MWh and 96,000 MWh of maximum load (8-23) at a price of UAH 3,270.8/MWh. Cherkasy chemical fiber and Euro-reconstruction sold 87,840 MWh of base load at weighted average prices of UAH 2,700/MWh, with April-May supply, Kharkiv CHP-5 – 229,320 MWh of base load at the weighted average price of UAH 2,307.14/MWh for the second quarter of 2023.
In the commercial sections, companies mainly purchased electricity by individual profile load, base load and block positions.
| Type of trades | Sales volume, MWh. |
|---|---|
| Auctions in fulfillment of Article 66 of the Law “On the Electricity Market” | 3 013 398 |
| Commercial section | 55 641,584 |
| Special sessions on the sale of electricity produced from alternative energy sources | 8 100 |
| In total | 3 077 139,584 |
As of March 31, prices were formed for the most frequently used types of sales charts, presented on the chart.
Market operator: day-ahead market and intraday market
During the review period, prices were stable, being in the range of UAH 2941.16 - 3228.16/MWh, within ± 4.6% of the deviation relative to the average weekly value. In general, the average value of the weighted average price for the last week is close to the similar indicator of the previous week and amounted to UAH 3134.55/MWh (-0.3 %). A total of 391.7 thousand MWh was realized at the DAM during the review period (-9.1 %).
During the review period, prices were more dynamic on the IDM. Average weighted prices varied in the range of 3070.72 - 3668.02 MWh, and the average value of weighted average prices for the review period decreased by 1.9% relative to the similar indicator of the previous period and amounted to UAH 3426.03/MWh. The total volume of sales during the review period amounted to 21.29 thousand MWh.
European market
Electricity prices in Europe rose last week compared to the previous week, driven by forecasts of colder temperatures, increased demand, higher natural gas prices and reduced renewable energy production in some markets, although several markets were negative or zero hourly prices earlier the week , which was caused by the increase in wind power generation.
Solar generation declined in Germany, Spain and Italy. Wind power generation in Europe in the first few days of last week provided 20% of the region’s needs, with Germany and Spain leading the way, while France fell. Demand grew due to a decrease in the average temperature in Europe.
As for hourly prices, low prices were registered in many European markets in the last days of the fourth week of March. The Spanish market registered a price of 0 EUR/MWh between 15:00 and 16:00 on Saturday, March 25, which has not been the case since the beginning of the year. This price was repeated on Sunday 26 March between 11:00 and 18:00 in both the Spanish and Portuguese markets. In the French, German and Belgian markets on Saturday, March 25, prices reached negative values at 4 am, 7 am and 2 pm. But the lowest hourly price, ‑ 20.02 EUR/MWh, was reached on Monday, March 27, from 15:00 to 16:00 on the Dutch market. This price was the lowest in this market since the end of August 2022. In the Netherlands market, on March 24, 25 and 27, the price of 0 EUR/MWh was registered for six hours, and negative prices for another eighteen hours.
As of March 31, 2023 the price of basic electricity in France was EUR 74.16/MWh, in Hungary - EUR 99.97/MWh, in Poland - EUR 124.16/MWh. As of April 2023, in the above-mentioned countries, electricity was traded at prices in the range of 108-110 EUR/MWh.
Monthly futures for May 2023 on electric energy increased in France by 1.6%, in Hungary by 7%. As of June 2023, prices have increased by 8% on average.
Prices of futures contracts, EUR/MWh, 30.03.2023
| Тype | Contract | Date | France | Hungary | Poland |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base | Моnth | Аpr/23 | 108,08 | 110,67 | |
| May/23 | 109,81 | 118,4 | 119,49 | ||
| Jun/23 | 122,85 | 129,7 | 122,45 |

EUA trading was quiet last week ahead of the Easter break period. As for futures settlement prices for the right to emit CO 2 on the EEX market under the benchmark contract from December 2023, they rose last week against the background of weak sales volumes. At the end of the week, futures on the benchmark quotation traded in the narrowest range since the beginning of the year. EEX CO 2 futures prices for benchmark December 2023 contracts reached a price of EUR 90.96/t on Thursday, March 30, 2023, down 1.7% from last year Thursday.
The spot price of coal in Europe increased slightly, although there are significant reserves of coal in the port terminals of northwestern Europe. On Thursday, March 30, the price of thermal coal in Europe (according to API-2) was 126.64 euros/ton, which is 1.5% higher than last week’s indicator.
There is a minor import of electricity. Last week, the technical possibility for imports was expanded by 150 MWh to 850 MWh. Its recovery is most likely in the summer.
Public procurements
Over 40 tenders for the purchase of electricity by customers were held last week. The realized volume of the 10 largest contracts is 14.23 million kWh for a total cost of UAH 55.22 million excluding VAT. In general, the average price was UAH 4.20 per kWh excluding VAT. The largest contract was awarded to "Lexar Technologies" LLC, which will supply 10.04 million kWh to CE "Khmelnytskyi Communal Enterprise "Electrotrans" electricity at the initial price of UAH 3.68. per kWh excluding VAT. Other tenders are shown in the graph below. Prices ranged from UAH 3.41 to UAH 5.63/kWh excluding VAT.
News of the wholesale electricity market
At the Berlin Energy Fransition Dialogue Herman Galushchenko noted that the future energy mix of Ukraine should be as follows: 50% is nuclear generation, which currently produces more than half of all electricity in Ukraine, and the remaining 50% will be produced by renewable energy sources.
The Spanish government has reached an agreement with the European Commission to extend the price ceiling in Spain and Portugal for natural gas used to generate electricity in gas, dual-fuel and cogeneration power plants until the end of December 2024. The gas price will be limited from EUR 55/MWh to EUR 65/MWh. The scheme helps to decouple gas prices from electricity prices and help consumers exposed to changes in the wholesale electricity market, which are about 40% of domestic consumers in Spain and between 70 and 80% of industrial consumption. The mechanism was created in May 2022.
As part of Vision 2030, the Czech state energy company ČEZ undertook to prepare the construction of small modular reactors (SMRs) with a total capacity of over 1,000 MWh in the Czech Republic . ČEZ has already signed memorandums of cooperation in the field of SMR with NuScale, GE Hitachi, Rolls Royce, EdF, Westinghouse, KHNP and Holtec. Having chosen the site of the Temelin nuclear power plant for the construction of the country’s first MMR, the company now plans to place the units in Detmarovytsy and Tushimitsy, which currently host coal-fired power plants with a capacity of 600 MWh and 800 MWh, respectively, in Tushimitsy.

