Electricity: Ukraine and Europe June 5 – 9, 2023

Ukrainian Energy Exchange: the bilateral contracts market
During the last week, 13 auctions for the purchase/sale of electricity were held at the UEEX in the one-way auction mode, of which 7 were in commercial sections and 6 were in specialized sections. Among the initiators were presented: Centerenergo, Guaranteed Buyer, Tyligulska WPP DTEK, USP and DSO, etc.
During the review period, the Guaranteed Buyer initiated the auction, offering block positions of daytime hours with June delivery. According to the results, the company realized 42,000 MWh by block positions at prices in the range of 2450 - 2686.76 UAH/MWh with delivery 11.06-20.06 and 21150 MWh of block positions at prices in the range of 2,400 - 2,633.78 UAH/MWh with delivery on 19.06. - 30.06.
Last week, Tyligulska WPP DTEK initiated an auction with an offer of 7,200 MWh of base load for the supply period in the second decade of June, selling electricity at a weighted average price of UAH 2,660/MWh.
In the commercial sections of the company, electricity was mainly purchased by the load of an individual profile.
| Type of trades | Sales volume, MWh |
|---|---|
| Auctions in fulfillment of Article 66 of the Law on the Electricity Market | 7 200 |
| Commercial section | 42 963,874 |
| Special sessions on the sale of electricity produced from alternative energy sources | 63 150 |
| In total | 113 313,874 |
As of June 9, prices were formed for the most frequently used types of sales charts presented on the chart.
Market operator: day-ahead market and intraday market
During the review period, there was an increase in the price of DAM, which was in the range of UAH 2,953.44 - 3,203.43/MWh, within ± 4% of the deviation relative to the average weekly value. In general, the average value of the weighted average price for the last week increased relative to the similar indicator of the previous week and amounted to UAH 3113.95/MWh (+3.5%). A total of 275.12 thousand MWh was sold at the DAM during the review period (-9.8%).
During the review period, prices were more dynamic on the IDM. The weighted average prices varied in the range of 2464.90 - 3381.04 MWh, and the average value of the weighted average prices for the review period decreased by 6.3% relative to the similar indicator of the previous period and amounted to UAH 2975.49/MWh. The total volume of sales during the review period amounted to 59.49 thousand MWh.
European market
Prices on European electricity markets rose last week on the back of rising CO2 and natural gas, as well as falling wind generation. An exception was the German market, where the increase in the share of RES restrained prices.
Solar generation decreased in Germany and Italy and increased in Spain. Wind power generation in Europe for three days last week provided 9.5% of the region’s needs, according to the WindEurope association. The leading countries were France, Germany, Spain and Sweden.
Last week, after the end of the holidays, demand for electricity recovered in the main analyzed European electricity markets. In the case of Poland, the Boże Ciało holiday, which was a holiday on June 8, contributed to the drop in demand in the country on a weekly basis.
Regarding hourly prices, negative hourly prices were registered on the markets of Belgium and France on June 3 and 4.
As of June 8, the basic electricity price in France was EUR 85.31/MWh. In the case of the French market, increased wind energy production stabilized prices. In Hungary, the price of basic electricity was 86.56 EUR/MWh, in Poland - 96.02 EUR/MWh. As of July 2023, in the above-mentioned countries, electricity was traded at prices in the range of EUR 87-95/MWh.
Monthly futures for August 2023 on electricity increased by an average of 3%. As of September 2023, prices increased by 10% on average in the analyzed countries.
Prices of futures contracts, EUR/MWh, 06/08/2023
| Type | Contract | Date | France | Hungary | Poland |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base | Моnth | Jul/23 | 86,52 | 95,28 | 95,04 |
| Aug/23 | 86,76 | 103,60 | 95,70 | ||
| Sep/23 | 101,79 | 113,52 | 98,34 |
European carbon prices rose 1.7% on Wednesday morning to their highest level in more than two weeks, as the market reacted to a nearly 13% jump in natural gas prices. EEX CO2 futures for the benchmark December 2023 contracts hit a settlement of EUR 83.99/t on Thursday, June 8, up 6.7% from last Thursday’s price. Demand for CO2 emission rights in the electricity sector has increased due to higher gas prices.
The spot price of coal in Europe increased during the last week. On Thursday, June 8, the price of thermal coal in Europe (according to API-2) was 104.63 EUR/ton, which is 20% higher than last week.
In Ukraine, more than 20,000 consumers were left without electricity due to the consequences of the destruction of the Kakhovska HPP by Russian troops. 129 transformer substations, two solar power plants, and a pumping station of the Kherson thermal power plant were flooded in the area of the water spill. A deficit was recorded in the power system and emergency assistance from Romania was called in.
Public procurements
Last week, 14 tenders were held for the purchase of electricity by customers. The sold volume of the 10 largest contracts is 3.38 million kWh for the total cost of UAH 12.97 million excluding VAT. In general, the average price was UAH 3.68 per kWh excluding VAT.
The largest contract was awarded to Ukrainskyi Strum LLC, which will supply 1.23 million kWh of electricity to the State Institution "Institute of Pediatrics, Obstetrics and Gynecology named after Academician O. M. Lukianova of the National Academy of Medical Sciences of Ukraine" at the initial price of UAH 3.93. per kWh excluding VAT. Other tenders are shown on the graph. Prices ranged from 3.25 to 4.33 UAH/kWh excluding VAT.
News of the wholesale electricity market
Germany is launching a scheme to support heavy industry linked to a price on carbon emissions. "The German government last week launched the multibillion-dollar Carbon Contracts for Difference (CCfD) program to help the country’s heavy industry covered by the EU ETS to decarbonize its operations," German Economy and Climate Minister Robert Habeck said on Monday.
The World Trade Organization has proposed a scheme to harmonize the pricing system for carbon emissions worldwide. The scheme classifies countries into four categories based on their development status and historical emissions, with the lowest price being USD 27 per tonne of carbon emitted for less developed countries and the highest being USD 181 per tonne for the richest. Thus, if the history of CO2 emissions is taken into account when creating carbon pricing models, richer countries will have to pay much more compared to others, because their contribution to pollution is bigger. The methodology can be used as a basis for calculating the equivalence of different climate policy measures around the world, which is not based on price.
NEURC intends to establish new maximum limit prices of electricity for DAM and IDM from June 30, 2023. At the meeting on Thursday, the NEURC approved the draft of the relevant resolution. According to the rationale for the draft resolution, limit prices will be set: on the "day-ahead" market (hereinafter - DAM): maximum limit prices for the hours of minimum load (from 00:00 to 07:00 and from 23:00 to 24:00) – UAH 2,706.63/MWh and for hours of maximum load (from 07:00 to 23:00) – UAH 5,413.26/MWh; minimum marginal price – UAH 10.00/MWh; on the intraday market (hereinafter - VDR): maximum limit prices for hours of minimum load (from 00:00 to 07:00 and from 23:00 to 24:00) - 2,706.63 UAH/MWh and for hours of maximum load (from 07:00 to 23:00) – UAH 5,413.26/MWh; on the balancing market: the maximum limit price is 125% of the DAM price determined by the market operator for each calculation period of the corresponding day of supply; the minimum marginal price is UAH 0.01/MWh.
In the market review of June 5, the EC stated that it does not recommend extending the Council Regulations on the limit of inframarginal income (in the amount of 180 EUR/MWh), which expires on June 30 as prices have fallen and a repeat of last year’s spikes this winter looks unlikely. Extending the validity of this regulations will hinder the key objective of the EC proposal to design the electricity market to encourage the adoption of power purchase agreements and to ensure that the PPA market is as liquid as possible, the report said. The cap was introduced on December 1, 2022 in response to a price increase of more than EUR 350/MWh in August.


