Electricity: Ukraine and Europe July 24 - 28, 2023

Ukrainian Energy Exchange: bilateral contracts market
During the last week 20 auctions for the purchase and sale of electricity in the unilateral mode auction were held at UEEX, of which 6 in commercial sections, 14 in specialized. Among the initiators are: Energoatom Trading, Centrenergo, Guaranteed Buyer, Donbasenergo, DTEK group companies, USP and DSO, etc.
Emergoatom Trading was initiator of the auction according to the Art.66 of the Law of Ukraine “On electricity market” on proposing base load with delivery in August. The Company was managed to sell 372000 MWh of base load with weighted average price UAH 3511,20 per MWh with delivery on August and 475200 MWh of base load with weighted average price UAH 3559,87 with delivery on 10-31 August.
The companies DTEK Kurakhivska TPP, Dniproenergo and Zahidenergo initiated auctions in accordance with Art. 66 of the Law of Ukraine "On electricity market", where block positions with a supply period in August were offered. Companies were able to sell 2519,93 thousand MWh, at prices in the range of UAH 2154 – 4981,98/MWh.
In the reporting period Centrenergo Company was initiated auctions with proposed base load and block positions with supply in August. As of its results the Company was managed to sell 168144 MWh of base load with the average weighted amount of UAH 3530,90 per MWh and 4960 MWh of block positions (8-23) with weighted average price UAH 4150 per MWh, 6448 MWh of block positions (12-14) with average weighted price UAH 4244,38 per MWh.
In addition, Donbasenergo sold 148800 MWh of base load electricity in specialized sections last week at a weighted average price of UAH 3542,4/MWh with delivery in August.
During the review period, auctions were initiated by the Guaranteed Buyer, offering block positions of daytime hours with delivery in August. According to the results, the company sold 166500 MWh. of electricity at prices in the range of UAH 1700,1 – 3452,03 per MWh. with different delivery times for August.
In commercial sections companies mainly purchased electricity with individual profile load.
| Trades type | Sale volume, MWh |
|---|---|
| Auctions in fulfillment of Article 66 of the Law of Ukraine “O electricity market” | 3 695 480 |
| Commercial section | 55 051,124 |
| Special sessions on the sale of electricity produced from alternative energy sources | 166 500 |
| Totaly | 3 917 031,124 |
As of July 28, the process for the most commonly used sales chart types were formed, which are presented on the table.
Market operator: day-ahead market and intraday market
During the reporting period, prices were dynamic, being in the range of UAH 3156,62 – 4602,55/MWh, within ±18% of the deviation relative to the average weekly value. In general, the average value of the weighted average price for the last week increased relative to the similar indicator of the previous week and amounted to UAH 3965,05/MWh. (+12%). A total of 402,73 thousand MWh were sold at DAM during the reporting period (+7.1%).
During the reporting period, prices were even more dynamic on the IDM. Average weighted prices varied in the range of 2614,87 – 4712,87 MWh, and the average value of weighted average prices for the reporting period decreased by 1,3% relative to the similar indicator of the previous period and amounted to UAH 3869,76/MWh. The total volume of purchase and sale during the review period amounted to 30,1 thousand MWh.
European market
Last week, energy markets were stress-tested as heatwaves intensified in southern Europe. As a result, prices in European electricity markets rose, which also led to an increase in demand for gas, with gas consumption for electricity generation rising sharply, especially in Italy. DA gas prices in Italy and Spain are currently significantly higher than in cooler NW Europe. Heat waves in the European region are also causing higher demand for cooling, as well as stability of supply, as river temperatures affect the operation of nuclear power plants and the efficiency of power plants. In Europe as a whole, wind and solar generation in the north, as well as cheap LNG generation in the south, keep the power system running without involving coal.
Solar generation increased in Spain and decreased in Italy and Germany.
Wind power generation in Europe in the first four days of last week provided 14.1% of the region’s needs, according to the WindEurope association. At the same time, the leading countries were Germany, Spain, France and Italy.
Last week, demand for electricity increased in most major European markets. Daily peak demand for electricity was higher in the range of 5 to 34% in the analyzed countries than at the beginning of the month. In the hottest countries, weekly demand averaged 30-38 GW per week. Current week demand is likely to increase further due to high temperature, but structural demand will decrease in August due to holidays.
Regarding hourly prices, on July 23, from 2:00 to 5:00, a price of 0.00 EUR/MWh was registered on the Spanish market and at the Portuguese Market from 4:00 p.m. to 5:00 p.m. Markets in Germany, Belgium, France and the Netherlands recorded negative prices on Friday, July 23 due to strong wind and solar generation combined with lower weekend consumption.
As of July 27, the basic electricity price in France was 92,79 euros/MWh, in Hungary 104,29 euros/MWh, in Poland 136,30 euros/MWh. As of August 2023, electricity was traded in Hungary at EUR 93,21/MWh, in Poland at EUR 117,51/MWh. August baseload contracts in France jumped on the trading day of July 26 to 73,36 euros/MWh. after settling at EUR 71,74/MWh on July 17, a two-year high for the M+1 contract, according to EEX. France’s EDF accelerated the restart of its 1.3 GW Cattenom-2 unit with July 19, although it was supposed to return on August 12 after preventive maintenance due to corrosion problems. Depending on how closely EDF sticks to its current repair schedule, France could go from a summer discount to a winter premium in the electricity market.
Monthly futures for September 2023 on electricity increased by an average of 9% in the analyzed countries. As of October 2023, prices increased by 12% in Hungary and 14% in France and decreased by 6% in Poland.
Prices of futures contracts, EUR/MWh, 27.07.2023
| Type | Contract | Date | France | Hungary | Poland |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base | Моnth | Aug/23 | 73,36 | 93,21 | 117,51 |
| Sep/23 | 87,16 | 98,81 | 120,98 | ||
| Oct/23 | 99,23 | 111,09 | 113,85 |
CO 2 futures prices on the EEX market for benchmark December 2023 contracts reached a settlement price of EUR 91,06/t on Thursday, July 27. Expectations of lower bids at the August auction drove the price up last week.
Thermal coal prices on the European market have risen over the past week amid expectations of record high temperatures. The spot price of thermal coal in Europe (according to API-2) on Thursday, July 27, was EUR 100,92/ton. Over the past week, 8 shipments of thermal coal arrived at European ports, containing a total of 386,300 tons of coal, which is 23% lower than the 503,200 tons of thermal coal that arrived in Europe a week earlier. The suppliers were the USA, Colombia, Latvia and the Netherlands. Europe’s thermal coal consumption will face further contraction with increased reliance on LNG as prices for imported thermal coal rise amid expectations of further heatwaves across the continent. The infrastructure for coal logistics will also prevent the use of more coal. There is a clear focus on LNG, even in periods when prices are higher.
Emergency aid from Romania was deployed last week. Russian attacks on energy facilities in Ukraine continue.
Public procurements
Last week, more than 20 tenders were held for the purchase of electricity by customers. Sold volume of the 10 largest contracts is 64,69 million kWh. for the total cost of UAH 244,49 million. excluding VAT. In general, the average price was UAH 4,14. per kWh excluding VAT. The largest contract was awarded to "Energoprod Service" LLC, which will supply 25,35 million kWh to Kyivmisksvitlo LLC of the outdoor lighting power grid of Kyiv electricity at the initial price of UAH 3,78 per kWh excluding VAT. Other tenders are shown in the graph below. Prices ranged from UAH 3,36 to UAH 5,60/kWh. excluding VAT.
News of the wholesale electricity market
NKREKP agreed to a 50/50 distribution of revenues from the sale of the import-export crossing ofelectricity between Ukraine and Romania. NEURC agreed on the procedure for the distribution of revenues from the management of restrictions between transmission system operators (TSOs) of Ukraine and Romania, provided by NEC "Ukrenergo". The corresponding decision was made at the meeting of the regulator on Wednesday. "To agree on the distribution of revenues from the management of restrictions, agreed by the DSO of Ukraine and Romania and determined by the draft agreement on the distribution of interzonal capacity between the trading zones of NEC "Ukrenergo" and C.N.T.E.E. Transelectrica S.A., by letter of "Ukrenergo" dd. July 25, 2023 No. 01/36002", is stated in the approved draft resolution of the NEURC.
According to analytical research, liquidity in the PPA sector in Europe has increased this year. Along with higher liquidity, the PPA market showed a shift in favor of longer terms, with 10-year terms being the most common in the year, immediately followed the 15-year terms. It is likely that 2023 will witness a record number of transactions. This is happening as smaller buyers enter the market. So far this year, more than 135 deals have already been concluded, which is still below last year’s record of 193 deals. If the year continues at this pace, more than 250 deals are expected. The PPA landscape in Europe also changed in 2023 as lower electricity prices and climate targets attracted more buyers. Traditionally, the PPA sector has been dominated by tech companies such as Amazon and Google, which power their data centers. However, a number of food and retail companies have become more active this year.
Energy Company of Ukraine offers 100% purchase of electricity from green generation and its balancing. The state-owned energy trader Energy Company of Ukraine (ECU) offers renewable electricity producers entering the free market a comprehensive offer: the possibility of 100% buyback of their electricity sales and simultaneous solution of the balancing issue. The proposal was presented by Vitaliy Butenko, CEO of Energy Company of Ukraine, at the Green Recovery of Ukraine conference held by Energy Club on July 27.


