Еlectricity: Ukraine and Europe February 12 – February 16, 2024

Ukrainian Energy Exchange: bilateral contracts market
Last week, the UEEX held 16 auctions for the purchase/sale of electricity in the unilateral auction mode, including 3 in commercial sections and 13 in specialized sections. The initiators included: Guaranteed Buyer, Centrenergo, Ukrhydroenergo, Nizhnednistrovska HPP, DTEK Group companies, DSOs and TSOs, etc.
Centrenergo initiated the auctions in accordance with Article 66 of the Law of Ukraine "On the Electricity Market", where it offered base load and block positions. As a result, the company sold 17336 MWh of the block position (24-7) at prices in the range of 2006.84 - 2027.74 UAH/MWh with delivery on February 19-29.
Ukrhydroenergo initiated the auction, offering block positions and base load. According to the results of the auction, 11328 MWh of block position (8-15) were sold at prices in the range of 3116.5 - 3130 UAH/MWh for delivery in February, 7824 MWh of block position (16-23) at prices in the range of 3750 - 3759.93 UAH/MWh with delivery in February and 12648 MWh of block position (8-15) at the weighted average price of 3229.41 UAH/MWh with delivery in March, 992 MWh of block position (16-23) at the weighted average price of 3677.5 UAH/MWh with delivery in March.
Last week, DTEK Kurakhivska TPP, Dniproenergo and Zakhidenergo initiated auctions in the specialized section in accordance with Article 66 of the Law of Ukraine "On the Electricity Market", offering block positions with a delivery period of the third decade of February. As a result of the auctions, the companies sold 580761 MWh of various block positions at prices in the range of 2100 - 3351.57 MWh.
During the reporting period, the Guaranteed Buyer initiated the auction, offering block positions for daytime hours with delivery in the third decade of February. According to the results of the auction, the company sold 23850 MWh of block positions at prices in the range of 2881.65 - 3253.3 UAH/MWh.
In the commercial sections, the companies mainly bought/sold electricity to individual loads.
| Type of trading | Sales volume, MWh |
|---|---|
| Auctions pursuant to Article 66 of the Law of Ukraine “On the Electricity Market” | 630 889 |
| Commercial section | 25 662,914 |
| Special sessions for the sale of electricity generated from alternative energy sources | 23 850 |
| In total | 680 401,914 |
As of February 16, prices for the most commonly used types of sales schedules were formed, as shown in the chart.
Market operator: day-ahead and intraday markets
During the reporting period, prices were dynamic, ranging from 2929.57 to 3890.94 UAH/MWh. In general, the average weighted average price for the last week decreased by 4.7% compared to the same indicator of the previous week and amounted to 3357.48 UAH/MWh. The highest daily price amounted to 3890.94 UAH/MWh on February 13, and the lowest - 2929.57 UAH/MWh on February 11. The volume of sales for the reporting period of February 10-16 amounted to 424.35 thousand MWh, (-2.7%).
During the reporting period, prices on the DAM were volatile. The weighted average prices varied in the range of 2917.57 - 3933.88 MWh, and the average value of the weighted average prices for the reporting period increased by 1.1% compared to the same period last year and amounted to 3470.02 UAH/MWh. The total volume of sales and purchases in the reporting period amounted to 32.72 thousand MWh.
European market
Last week, electricity prices in most countries remained at levels similar to those recorded since the second half of January. CO2 prices continued to fall and registered their lowest prices last Tuesday, stopping at the price level last seen in the early days of the war in Ukraine. Market experts note that the liquidity of European electricity futures has increased. Europe’s ambitious environmental goals "lead to a significant contribution of renewable energy sources to the energy balance." As the of renewable energy sources increases, standard products traded on exchanges become less sensitive to risk requirements. In Germany or Spain, six or seven years ago, the market was trading only four or five years ahead. In Spain and Germany, electricity futures are now quoted for at least 10 years.
Electricity generation by wind turbines in Europe over four days last week covered 19% of the region’s needs, according to the WindEurope Association. The leading countries were Germany, the UK, France and Spain. Solar power generation continued to grow in line with the trend of growth as the days get longer. Germany, Italy, and Spain recorded growth last week.
The downward trend in demand continued in France for the fifth week in a row, and demand also declined in Spain and Belgium. In the Italian and German markets, after a three-week decline, the demand trend changed to an upward one.
In terms of hourly prices, the MIBEL market reached prices below EUR 1/MWh for eight consecutive hours on Saturday, February 10. In particular, from 11:00 to 17:00, the price on the Iberian market was 0 euros/MWh. The high level of renewable energy generation during hours with lower demand led to such prices.
As of February 16, the price of basic electricity in France amounted to 60.75 EUR/MWh. EDF extended the shutdown at Chinon 4 (905 MWh) until February 17, which was stopped last Saturday after a fire broke out in an electrical transformer at the subsidiary Chinon-3 power unit.
As of February 16, the price of basic electricity in Hungary amounted to 62.20 EUR/MWh. Gas prices have recently become the main driver of electricity prices in Hungary, with local fundamentals having less of an impact. Local traders said they expect this trend to continue unless there is some unforeseen market event. In Poland, the price of basic electricity as of February 16 amounted to 74.56 EUR/MWh.
As of March 2024, electricity was traded in the range of 56-76 EUR/MWh in the analyzed countries. Monthly electricity futures for April 2024 decreased by an average of 5% in France and Hungary and increased by 3% in Poland. As of May 2024, prices decreased by 6% on average in the analyzed countries.
In Germany, during the February 14 trading session, the Y+1 contract traded at EUR 71.51/MWh under pressure from forecasts of mild temperatures and falling gas prices. This was the lowest level since July 2021.
Prices of futures contracts, EUR/MWh, February 15, 2024
| Type | Contract | Date | France | Hungary | Poland |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base | Моnth | Mar/24 | 55,78 | 64,62 | 76,07 |
| Аpr/24 | 52,37 | 61,91 | 78,32 | ||
| May/24 | 46,39 | 58,36 | 77,34 |

Prices for CO2 emission rights futures on the EEX market for the benchmark December 2024 contracts declined for six consecutive days until last Thursday, when the trend was interrupted by news that EU carbon allowances no longer needed by German coal-fired power plants that are being decommissioned as part of the mandatory coal phase-out are to be permanently removed from the market. The settlement price last Thursday, February 15, amounted to 57.91 euros per tonne, which is 1.8% lower than the previous week.
Estimates and targets for a 90% reduction in emissions below 1990 levels, presented by the European Commission after the creation of the European SMRs Industry Alliance on February 6, suggest that the deployment of small modular reactors could help reduce emissions by 90% by 2040. The EU’s installed nuclear capacity is projected to decline from around 110 GW in 2015 to 94 GW in 2030 and 71 GW in 2040 and 2050. In addition, nuclear power is projected to supply 129 million tons of oil equivalent in the 27 EU member states in 2040, compared to 139 million tons of oil equivalent in 2030.
On February 15, the spot price of thermal coal in Europe (according to API-2) amounted to 87.89 EUR/ton, which is 3% lower than the previous Thursday.
Last week, Russia continued to destroy the energy sector in the frontline regions, with shelling of generation and distribution facilities.
During night and daytime hours, electricity was exported to Slovakia, Romania, Moldova, and Poland. Electricity was imported from Slovakia, Romania, Moldova, and Poland.
Public procurement
Over the past week, more than 70 tenders for the purchase of electricity by customers were held. The realized volume of the 10 largest contracts amounted to 103.76 million kWh for a total value of UAH 399.44 million excluding VAT. Overall, the average price amounted to UAH 4.64 per kWh, excluding VAT. The largest contract was awarded to Energy Company of Ukraine JSC, which will supply 75.84 million kWh of electricity to Zaporizhzhiaoblenergo at an initial price of UAH 3.42 per kWh, excluding VAT. Other tenders are shown in the graph below. The prices ranged from UAH 3.42 to 6.90 per kWh.
News from the wholesale electricity market
In late February, the first joint auctions for the allocation of cross-border capacity between Ukraine and Moldova will begin – the monthly auction for March 2024 will be held on February 20, and the daily auction for the delivery date of March 01, 2024 will be held on February 29. The auctions will be held on the platform of NPC Ukrenergo.
Also, changes have been made to the schedule of joint daily auctions for the directions Ukraine - Moldova and Moldova - Ukraine (Kyiv time), namely:
10:00 D-1 - publication of the terms and conditions of daily auctions;
10:15 D-1 - opening of the price bid gate;
11:00 D-1 - closing of the gate for submission of price bids;
11:30 D-1 - announcement of the auction results.
Ukraine increased electricity exports in mid-February. In terms of the day, exports take place during the "daytime" hours, when solar generation is most active, and at night during off-peak hours, as evidenced by ExPro monitoring based on ENTSO-E Transparency Platform data. The largest amount of electricity was exported on February 10 - 2807 MWh. In total, over 15 days of February, 62.5 thousand MWh were imported and 20.3 thousand MWh were exported.

