Electricity: Ukraine and Europe April 8 – 12, 2024

Ukrainian Energy Exchange: bilateral contracts market
Last week, the UEEX held 14 auctions for the purchase/sale of electricity in the unilateral auction mode, including 5 in commercial sections and 9 in specialized sections. The initiators included: Guaranteed Buyer, Ukrhydroenergo, USP and DSOs, etc.
Ukrhydroenergo initiated auctions to offer block positions and base load. According to the results, the company sold 69408 MWh of baseload at prices in the range of 2407.67 - 2721.67 UAH/MWh with delivery in April, 13680 MWh of block positions (1-12) at a weighted average price of 2070.33 UAH/MWh, 4788 MWh of block positions (13-24) at a weighted average price of 2955.24 UAH/MWh with delivery during April.
In addition, in the specialized section last week, Centrenergo initiated auctions in accordance with Article 66 of the Law of Ukraine "On the Electricity Market", where it offered base load with delivery in the second decade of April. As a result of the auctions, the company was unable to sell electricity. As a result of a massive missile attack on April 11, Russian troops completely destroyed the Trypillia thermal power plant in Kyiv region. Currently, Centrenergo has lost 100% of its generation.
During the reporting period, the Guaranteed Buyer initiated the auction, offering block positions of daytime hours with different deliveries during April. According to the results of the auction, the company sold 78400 MWh of block positions at prices in the range of UAH 1240 - 2268.15/MWh.
In the commercial sections, the companies bought/sold electricity to loads with individual profiles.
| Type of trades | Sales volume, MWh |
|---|---|
| Auctions pursuant to Article 66 of the Law of Ukraine On Electricity Market | 87 876 |
| Commercial section | 54 306,608 |
| Special sessions for the sale of electricity generated from alternative energy sources | 78 400 |
| In total | 220 582,608 |
As of April 12, prices for the most commonly used types of sales schedules were formed, as shown in the chart.
Market operator: day-ahead and intraday markets
During the reporting period, the day-ahead market prices were volatile, ranging from 1251.22 to 2935.52 UAH/MWh. In general, the average weighted average price for the last week decreased by 42% compared to the same indicator last week and amounted to 2248.81 UAH/MWh. The highest daily price amounted to UAH 2935.52/MWh on April 11, and the lowest - UAH 1251.22/MWh on April 7. The volume of sales for the reporting period of April 6-12 amounted to 419.3 thousand MWh (-19%).
Prices for IDM were volatile during the review period. The weighted average prices varied in the range of 1699.59 - 3112.18 MWh, and the average value of the weighted average prices for the reporting period decreased by 31% compared to the same period last year and amounted to 2424.09 UAH/MWh. The total volume of sales and purchases for the reporting period amounted to 37 thousand MWh.
European market
Last week, prices in the analyzed European electricity markets began to rise, driven by a partial recovery in demand, rising prices for carbon dioxide emission allowances in Europe, and a decrease in wind power generation in most markets. Spot electricity prices in Europe rose sharply at the end of the week as temperatures are expected to fall 3°C below normal next week and due to rising carbon prices.
Electricity generation from wind turbines in Europe in the first three days of last week provided 22.17% of the region’s needs, according to the WindEurope Association. The leading countries were Germany, France, Sweden, Spain and the UK.
Solar power generation increased last week in Germany and Spain. The Italian market set a record for photovoltaic generation on April 6 with the second highest value in history, 119 GWh, only 190 MWh below the historical record set on June 17, 2023.
In the second week of April, electricity demand in most major European electricity markets continued the downward trend of the previous weeks.
As for hourly prices, most major European electricity markets registered negative prices. The Dutch market reached the lowest hourly price: -125.30 EUR/MWh, on Saturday, April 6, from 14:00 to 15:00. For the second time in their history, the Spanish and Portuguese markets registered negative prices, which was repeated for several hours on April 6, 7 and 8. On Sunday, April 7, the Nord Pool market in the Nordic countries registered negative hourly prices for the first time since October 2023. There were no negative prices on the Italian market, but the price of 0.10 euros/MWh on April 7 from 13:00 to 14:00 was the lowest for this time on the market since April 2020.
As for daily prices, on Saturday, April 6, the French market reached a negative price of -0.71 EUR/MWh. This price was the lowest since early July 2023 and the only negative price since then on this market.
As of April 12, the price of basic electricity in France amounted to 21.04 EUR/MWh, due to the increased availability of nuclear power in France. As of April 12, the price of basic electricity in Hungary amounted to 58.02 EUR/MWh, in Poland 84.19 EUR/MWh.
As of May 2024, electricity was traded in the range of 31-76 EUR/MWh in the analyzed countries.
Monthly electricity futures for June 2024 increased by an average of 22% in the countries analyzed. As of July 2024, prices decreased by 21.8% on average in France and Hungary.
Germany’s benchmark energy contract Cal 25 rose to €89.95/MWh on Thursday, reaching its highest level since January, while M+1 rose to EUR 62.27/MWh, the highest since March 25.
Futures contracts prices, EUR/MWh, 11.04.2024
| Type | Contract | Date | France | Hungary | Poland |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base | Моnth | May/24 | 30,86 | 62,36 | 76,14 |
| Jun/24 | 43,85 | 69,06 | 86,24 | ||
| Jul/24 | 58,26 | 76,53 | - |
CO 2 emission rights futures on the EEX market have been rising since the beginning of last week, hitting a 10-day high on Tuesday, reflecting the upward trend in gas prices, and setting a new 11-week high on Thursday as energy prices jumped after Russia attacked Ukrainian energy and gas facilities. The settlement price last Thursday, April 11, amounted to 68.03 euros per ton, which is 16% higher than the previous Thursday.
According to carbon market analysts, the record decline in CO2 emissions recorded in Europe in 2023 was partly due to "demand destruction" in a number of energy-intensive industries, which may prove to be "permanent" due to high gas prices and carbon pricing policies.
On April 10, the spot price of thermal coal in Europe (according to API-2) amounted to 109.97 euros per ton.
Russia’s shelling of Ukrainian energy facilities since the beginning of the month has been more widespread than in the previous two years, knocking out generating capacity and limiting electricity supplies. The main targets of Russian strikes were thermal and hydroelectric power plants.
Electricity was imported from Slovakia, Romania, Moldova, Hungary, and Poland. Exports were directed to Moldova, Slovakia, Romania, Hungary, and Poland.
Public procurement
Over the last week, more than 20 tenders for the purchase of electricity by customers were held. The sold volume of the 10 largest contracts amounted to 10.13 million kWh for a total value of UAH 42.92 million excluding VAT. The average price amounted to UAH 4.07 per kWh, excluding VAT. The largest contract was awarded to Operator Energy LLC, which will supply 5.5 million kWh of electricity to the Municipal Clinical Hospital No. 10 of Odesa City Council at a starting price of UAH 4.43 per kWh, excluding VAT. Other tenders are shown in the graph below. Prices ranged from UAH 2.72 to UAH 6.15 per kWh.
News from the wholesale electricity market
The Regulator proposes to cancel price lists for DAM and IDR from May
The Regulator proposes to cancel the price caps on the day-ahead and intraday markets from May 1, 2024. The relevant draft decision will be submitted for consideration at the NEURC meeting on April 16. «In order to minimize the regulatory impact on the electricity market, as well as to ensure its functioning on a competitive market basis and to liberalize the electricity market, the Energy Market Department submits a draft decision to the Commission to cancel the price caps on the day-ahead and intraday markets from May 1, 2024. At the same time, the current price caps on the balancing market will remain unchanged," the draft resolution states. As noted by the Regulator, actual prices on the day-ahead and intraday markets in the vast majority of billing periods since the beginning of 2024 have not reached the level of the price caps.
Lithuania wants to dismantle its closed TPPs and transfer equipment to Ukraine
The Lithuanian Ministry of Energy has offered to dismantle its closed thermal power plants for spare parts and transfer the equipment to the Ukrainian energy system. Energy Minister Herman Halushchenko said this during a telethon. "I had a conversation with the Minister of Energy of Lithuania. They actually offered to use their thermal power plants, which are closed. They offered to use them as donors, which means we can disassemble them and get the parts we need," he said. As a reminder, Ukraine needs to strengthen its air defense system to protect energy facilities from Russian missile attacks in order to prevent power outages in the summer, when electricity consumption is approaching its winter peak. In the summer, Ukrainians are likely to face blackouts and restrictions on electricity consumption.


