Electricity: Ukraine and Europe 19 – 23 February, 2024

Ukrainian energy exchange: bilateral contracts market
Last week, the UEEX held 15 auctions for the purchase/sale of electricity in the unilateral auction mode, including 4 in commercial sections and 11 in specialized sections. Among the initiators were: Energoatom-Trading, Guaranteed Buyer, Centrenergo, Ukrhydroenergo, USPs and DSOs, etc.
Energoatom-Trading initiated two trading sessions, which resulted in the sale of 14860 MWh of baseload at a weighted average price of 2701 UAH/MWh with a delivery period in March.
Centrenergo initiated auctions in accordance with Article 66 of the Law of Ukraine "On the Electricity Market", where it offered base load and block positions. As a result, the company failed to sell electricity.
In addition, in the specialized section last week, Ukrhydroenergo initiated an auction in accordance with Article 66 of the Law of Ukraine "On the Electricity Market", where block positions and base load were offered. According to the results, the company sold 448 MWh of block positions (8-15) at a weighted average price of 3000 UAH/MWh, 3136 MWh of block positions (16-23) at a weighted average price of 3417,55 UAH/MWh and 4480 MWh of block positions (24-7) at a weighted average price of 2056,86 UAH/MWh with a delivery period of the end of February. Block positions with a delivery period during March were also sold: 19840 MWh of the block position (16-23) at prices in the range of 3409,38 - 3454,69 UAH/MWh, 44213 MWh of the block position (24-7) at prices in the range of 1906,44 - 1933,26 UAH/MWh and 248 MWh of the block position (8-15) at a weighted average price of 3000 UAH/MWh.
During the reporting period, the Guaranteed Buyer initiated the auction, offering block positions for daytime hours with delivery in February and March. According to the results of the auction, the company sold 120 MWh of block positions at a weighted average price of 2750 UAH/MWh with delivery by the end of February and 15975 MWh of block positions at prices in the range of 2530 - 2790 UAH/MWh with delivery in March.
In the commercial sections, the companies mainly bought/sold electricity to individual loads.
| Type of trading | Sales volume, MWh |
|---|---|
| Auctions pursuant to Article 66 of the Law of Ukraine On Electricity Market | 87 225 |
| Commercial section | 92 461,95 |
| Special sessions for the sale of electricity generated from alternative energy sources | 16 095 |
| Totaly | 195 781,95 |
As of February 23, prices for the most commonly used types of sales schedules were formed, as shown in the chart below.
Market operator: day-ahead and intraday markets
During the reporting period, prices were dynamic, ranging from 2758,51 to 3445,34 UAH/MWh.d. Overall, the average weighted average price for the last week decreased by 8,9% compared to the same indicator of the previous week and amounted to 3084,46 UAH/MWh. The highest daily price amounted to 3445,34 UAH/MWh on February 20, and the lowest - 2758,51 UAH/MWh on February 23, (-1,3%).
During the reporting period, prices on the DAM were volatile. The weighted average prices varied in the range of 2714,11 - 3283,83 MWh, and the average value of the weighted average prices for the reporting period decreased by 13,5% compared to the same period last year and amounted to 3056,16 UAH/MWh. The total volume of purchases and sales for the reporting period amounted to 32,87 thousand MWh.
European market
Last week, electricity prices remained stable in most countries. Mostly, average prices were below 70 euros/MWh amid a drop in the average price of natural gas and CO2 emission rights. Market traders note that the market is currently oversupplied: France and the Czech Republic produce cheap nuclear power, and Austria and Switzerland produce cheap hydroelectric power.
Electricity generation from wind turbines in Europe over four days last week covered 22,1% of the region’s needs, according to the WindEurope Association. The leading countries were Germany, the UK, France and Spain. Solar power generation continued to grow in Germany and Spain. In Italy, a decrease was recorded last week.
The downward trend in demand continued in Italy. Demand increased in Germany, where last week the amount of demand not covered by renewable energy sources amounted to 26,1 GW. Demand growth also occurred in France (55,6 GW on average), Spain, Belgium, Portugal, the UK and the Netherlands. In addition, mild weather limits demand for heating. According to the SMHI meteorological service, the Nordic countries are expected to experience above-normal temperatures in the next two weeks, as well as relatively stable wind power generation.
As for hourly prices, in Spain, from 14:00 to 16:00 CET, the minimum price was 0,01 EUR/MWh on expectations of record wind generation on Friday, February 23. On Friday, the spot price for electricity in Spain on the Omie exchange fell to a 3,5-month low and amounted to 6,72 EUR/MWh.
As of February 23, the price of basic electricity in France amounted to 45,64 EUR/MWh. Some support for prices in the short term may be provided by the start of the maintenance season in France in March.
As of February 23, the price of basic electricity in Hungary amounted to 58,08 EUR/MWh, in Poland 66,88 EUR/MWh.
In March 2024, electricity was traded in the range of 51-67 EUR/MWh in the countries analyzed. Monthly electricity futures for April 2024 decreased by an average of 7,5% in France and Hungary and increased by 5% in Poland. As of May 2024, prices decreased by 5,6% on average in the analyzed countries.
The annual contract in Germany for electricity has lost almost 50% of its value since mid-November 2023 and last week Cal 25 was trading at just under 70 EUR/MWh. According to BayWa Re, Germany may be in a technical recession, which could further reduce demand in the future. At the moment, the main factors are the availability of gas, coal, and low EUA prices.
On Thursday, the French Cal 25 approached a three-year low and traded on the EEX exchange at 66,70 EUR/MWh. This price was formed due to high gas reserves and low carbon prices.
Futures contract prices, EUR/MWh, February 22, 2024
| Type | Contract | Date | France | Hungary | Poland |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base | Моnth | Mar/24 | 50,66 | 59,01 | 59,01 |
| Аpr/24 | 45,27 | 56,44 | 70,08 | ||
| May/24 | 41,62 | 52,93 | 68,43 |

Prices for CO 2 futures on the EEX market for the benchmark December 2024 contracts have been declining and reached a 31-month low last week. The settlement price last Thursday, February 22, amounted to 52,80 EUR per tonne, which is 1,4% lower than the previous Thursday and 34% lower than its value since mid-November. Analysts predict that EUA prices will continue to fall to a three-year low as the impact of lower natural gas prices spreads to the rest of the energy sector and demand from eligible buyers remains weak, making 2024 "a year to build strategic long positions."
According to the first comprehensive analysis of the bloc’s climate investments, investments in a clean transition need to reach EUR 813 billion a year this decade - double the amount spent in 2022 - if the EU is to meet its 2030 climate target and ensure the success of the European Green Deal.
Spot price of thermal coal in Europe (according to API-2) on February 22 amounted to 88 EUR/ton, which is 0,2% higher than the previous Thursday.
Last week, russia continued to shell energy facilities and destroy the energy sector in the frontline regions.
Ukraine’s energy system experienced a surplus and exports were made to Slovakia, Romania, Moldova, Poland and Hungary. Electricity was imported from Slovakia, Romania, Moldova, Hungary, and Poland.
Public procurement
Over the past week, more than 80 electricity procurement tenders were held by customers. The 10 largest contracts amounted to 24,92 million kWh for a total value of UAH 112,16 million excluding VAT. The average price amounted to UAH 4,64 per kWh, excluding VAT. The largest contract was awarded to Energy Markets Assistance LLC, which will supply 7 million kWh of electricity to the Chernivtsi Trolleybus Management Utility at an initial price of UAH 4,77 per kWh, excluding VAT. Other tenders are shown in the graph below. Prices ranged from UAH 3,73 to UAH 6,45 per kWh.
News of the wholesale electricity market
The Nord Pool energy exchange plans to introduce a mechanism that will allow setting stricter limits on the amount of electricity that individual market players can offer at the DA auction. New limits, for example, will prevent individual participants from offering more electricity at the auction than the generation portfolio they manage in the market. However, Nord Pool has yet to decide whether the limits will be voluntary or mandatory.
Bulgaria and Romania are reviving a EUR 6 billion project to build a hydroelectric power plant on the Dunay. Bulgaria’s National Electricity Company (NEK) and Romania’s Hidroelectrica are reviving a project to build a joint hydroelectric power plant on the Dunay River between the cities of Nikopol in Bulgaria and Turnu Magurele in Romania. Bulgarian Energy Minister Roumen Radev said, according to Intellinews. According to NEK CEO Martin Georgiev, the project was developed 50 years ago and involves the construction of a second bridge on the Dunay to connect two countries. The construction is estimated to cost both countries EUR 6 billion. "This is a cross-border project, where the hydroelectric power plant is only a small part of the benefits - it is also an important infrastructure project that will provide a connection between the two countries," Georgiev said. He added that both countries are currently updating old projects, reviewing them from a technical and environmental perspective. The hydropower plant is expected to have a capacity of 800 MW.

