Electricity: Ukraine and Europe 11 – 15 March, 2024

Ukrainian energy exchange: bilateral contracts market
Last week, UEEX held 13 auctions for the purchase/sale of electricity in the unilateral auction mode, including 6 in commercial sections and 7 in specialized sections. The initiators included: Guaranteed Buyer, Centrenergo, Ukrhydroenergo, DTEK Zakhidenergo, Cherkasy Chemical Fiber, USP and DSOs, etc.
Ukrhydroenergo initiated the auction, offering block positions and base load. As a result, the company sold 37320 MWh of baseload at a weighted average price of UAH 2411,67/MWh with delivery from March 19 to March 31.
Centrenergo initiated auctions in accordance with Article 66 of the Law of Ukraine "On the Electricity Market", where it offered base load with different delivery periods during March, April and for the second quarter. The company was unable to sell the volumes of electricity it offered.
DTEK Zakhidenergo initiated an auction offering base load with a supply period for the second quarter. As a result of the auction, the company was unable to sell electricity.
In addition, in the specialized section last week, Cherkasy Khim Volokno initiated an auction in accordance with Article 66 of the Law of Ukraine "On the Electricity Market", where it offered base load. As a result, the company sold 10050 MWh of baseload at a weighted average price of 2300 UAH/MWh, with a delivery period from March 18 to March 31.
During the reporting period, the Guaranteed Buyer initiated the auction, offering block positions of daytime hours with different delivery during March. According to the results of the auction, the company sold 126775 MWh of block positions at prices in the range of 1130,41 - 1991,7 UAH/MWh.
In commercial sections companies were selling/purchasing electricity with individual profile load.
| Trades type | Sales volume, MWh |
|---|---|
| Auctions pursuant to Article 66 of the Law of Ukraine On Electricity Market | 47 370 |
| Commercial section | 30 987 |
| Special sessions for the sale of electricity generated from alternative energy sources | 126 775 |
| Totaly | 205 132 |
As of March 15, prices for the most commonly used types of sales schedules were formed, as shown in the chart below.
Market operator: day-ahead and intraday markets
During the reporting period, the day-ahead market prices were volatile, ranging from 2135,65 to 3639,35 UAH/MWh. Overall, the average weighted average price over the past week increased by 18% compared to the same indicator last week and amounted to 2895,51 UAH/MWh. The highest daily price was 3639,35 UAH/MWh on March 13, and the lowest was 2135,65 UAH/MWh on March 10. The volume of sales for the reporting period of March 9-15 amounted to 469,05 thousand MWh, (+3.5%).
During the reporting period, prices on the IDM were volatile. The weighted average prices varied in the range of 2457,75 - 3741,56 MWh, and the average value of the weighted average prices for the reporting period increased by 33% compared to the same period last year and amounted to 2960,62 UAH/MWh. The total volume of purchases and sales for the reporting period amounted to 50,2 thousand MWh.
European market
The upward trend in prices on European electricity markets, which had been observed since early March, paused last week, and prices fluctuated along with the volatility of natural gas prices. Due to forecasts of continued mild temperatures and an increase in renewable energy generation, which reduces the need for gas-fired generation, prices declined at the end of the week.
Electricity generation by wind turbines in Europe over four days last week provided 16,6% of the region’s needs, according to the WindEurope Association. The leading countries were Germany and the UK. Germany recorded an increase in wind energy production with a weekly average of about 16,4 GW. Significant volumes of wind power generation in Spain have pushed nuclear power out of the supply mix amid seasonally subdued demand: nuclear power generation in Spain was roughly halved the weekend before last, as three of the seven plants were suspended and even before that were operating at reduced speeds.
Last week, demand fell in the markets of France to a weekly average of 51,1 GW and in Spain, Italy and Belgium. Demand in Germany averaged 53,3 GW.
As for the daily prices, on Sunday, March 10, the MIBEL market in Spain and Portugal averaged 0,54 EUR/MWh. This price was the lowest since February 2014 in the Iberian market. Hourly prices in this market from March 8 to 10 registered 38 hours with a price of 0 EUR/MWh due to a combination of high renewable energy generation and low demand.
The German market also recorded 7 hours with negative prices on March 9 and 10. The Dutch market recorded 11 hours with negative prices from March 8 to 10. The lowest hourly price, -39,79 EUR/MWh, was reached on the Dutch market on March 9 from 13:00 to 14:00. This price was the lowest on this market since the first half of August 2023.
As of March 15, the price of basic electricity in France amounted to 42,67 EUR/MWh.
As of March 15, the price of basic electricity in Hungary amounted to 59,40 EUR/MWh, in Poland 67,64 EUR/MWh.
As of April 2024, electricity was traded in the range of 48-67 EUR/MWh in the countries analyzed.
Monthly electricity futures for May 2024 decreased by an average of 9% in France and Hungary, and increased by 7,6% in Poland. As of June 2024, prices increased by 15% on average in the analyzed countries.
On Friday, Cal 25 was trading at 77,40 EUR/MWh in anticipation of the German economy’s industrial demand growth. Icis, a consulting company, expects a "moderate recovery of 5,6% year-on-year this year" in electricity demand in the European steel sector after a five-year decline amid a recession in the construction industry. European electricity demand is also expected to grow by 2,7% year-on-year in 2025.
Futures contract prices, EUR/MWh, March 14, 2024
| Type | Contract | Date | France | Hungary | Poland |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base | Моnth | Apr/24 | 47,71 | 60,70 | 67,20 |
| May/24 | 42,58 | 56,58 | 72,34 | ||
| Jun/24 | 52,77 | 63,90 | 78,34 |
Prices for CO2 emission rights futures on the EEX market traded mostly in a tight range for most of last week after sharp movements the week before last, when owners of coal and gas-fired power plants were scrambling to hedge their assets for the summer season. The settlement price last Thursday, March 14, was 58,45 EUR per tonne, down 1.2% from the previous Thursday. On March 15, in the morning, the price rose to 58,6 EUR per ton, tracking the rise in TTF and NBP prices. The decrease in the volume of the auction, which is expected next week, also affected prices, prompting traders to cover positions.
The decline in carbon prices by about 30% since the beginning of the year was partly due to the European Commission’s sales of RePowerEU. The auctioning of additional allowances caused the price to fall.
Three major oil companies, Norway’s Equinor, Britain’s Shell and France’s TotalEnergies, which have shown interest in CCS technologies in recent years, will manage carbon transportation and storage through their newly formed joint venture Northern Lights. This venture will provide cross-border transportation and storage of CO2 in the North Sea. With the Longship project, the Norwegian government aims to show the world that CCS technology can be used to safely store carbon underground.
On March 14, the spot price of thermal coal in Europe (API-2) amounted to 102,26 EUR per ton, which is 1,74% higher than the week before last.
Experts estimate that Turkey will overtake Poland to become the second largest coal-fired electricity producer in Europe in 2023 due to its growing dependence on fossil fuel imports and the instability of wind capacity installation.
No shortages are expected in the energy system, according to the transmission system operator. No outage schedules were applied. Exports from Ukraine’s power system went to Slovakia, Romania, Moldova, Poland and Hungary with a maximum capacity of up to 448 MW in some hours. Electricity was imported in the morning and evening hours from Slovakia, Romania, Moldova, Hungary, and Poland.
Public procurements
Over the past week, more than 30 tenders were held for the purchase of electricity by customers. Sold volume of the 10 largest contracts amounted to 9,15 million kWh for a total value of UAH 30,97 million excluding VAT. The average price amounted to UAH 3,94 per kWh, excluding VAT. The largest contract was awarded to Energy Markets Assistance LLC, which will supply 5,97 million kWh of electricity to the Production Department of Water Supply and Sewerage at an initial price of UAH 2,96 per kWh, excluding VAT. Other tenders are shown in the graph below. Prices ranged from UAH 2,78 to UAH 5,32 per kWh.
News of the wholesale electricity market
The second power unit of Khmelnytsky NPP was put under emergency repair. The second power unit of Khmelnytsky NPP has been disconnected from the grid. This was reported by Energoatom. "Yesterday, March 13, at 17:48, fluctuations in the axial displacement of the rotor of the high-pressure cylinder of the turbine unit (HPC) were recorded with an upward trend. Given the surplus in the electricity market, it was decided to shut down the turbine unit to find out and eliminate the cause of the deviation," the nuclear company said in a statement. Currently, 7 power units of the nuclear power plant are in operation. The total capacity of the nuclear power plant is 5900 MW.
The Government approved the procedure for electricity exports by Guaranteed Buyer. The Cabinet of Ministers has approved the Procedure for the Export of Electricity by the State Enterprise Guaranteed Buyer. It sets out the requirements for setting the minimum selling price for electricity exports by Guaranteed Buyer, the specifics of holding an auction to determine the counterparty to the export contract and the company’s participation in auctions for the allocation of access to cross-border transmission capacity. The market has repeatedly discussed the need for Guaranteed Buyer to export electricity to minimize losses of green electricity and generate additional funds.


